| May 6, 1998 | LALA Galaxy7–4ColoradoCOL | Regular | 11 | 12,013 | 60 |
| May 2, 1996 | KCKansas City6–4ColumbusCLB | Regular | 10 | 8,848 | 60 |
| Aug 26, 2000 | DALDallas4–6MetroStarsMET | Regular | 10 | 12,940 | 70 |
| May 8, 2004 | SJSan Jose5–5MetroStarsMET | Regular | 10 | 7,522 | 70 |
| Aug 1, 2015 | DCD.C.6–4Salt LakeRSL | Regular | 10 | 17,288 | 60 |
| May 24, 2026 | MIAMiami6–4PhiladelphiaPHI | Regular | 10 | — | 60 |
| Jun 4, 1998 | DALDallas1–8LA GalaxyLA | Regular | 9 | 10,047 | 70 |
| Jun 16, 2001 | COLColorado3–6DallasDAL | Regular | 9 | 12,652 | 70 |
| Jun 2, 2002 | CHIChicago5–4ColumbusCLB | Regular | 9 | 10,241 | 70 |
| Sep 17, 2005 | METMetroStars5–4New EnglandNE | Regular | 9 | 17,031 | 70 |
| May 20, 2006 | RBNYRed Bulls5–4Chivas USACHV | Regular | 9 | 9,573 | 70 |
| Aug 18, 2007 | RBNYRed Bulls5–4LA GalaxyLA | Regular | 9 | 66,237 | 80 |
| Sep 27, 2008 | RBNYRed Bulls4–5ColoradoCOL | Regular | 9 | 14,795 | 80 |
| Sep 12, 2009 | LALA Galaxy3–6DallasDAL | Regular | 9 | 18,148 | 70 |
| May 10, 2014 | RBNYRed Bulls4–5ChicagoCHI | Regular | 9 | 23,776 | 80 |
| Aug 4, 2019 | COLColorado6–3MontrealMTL | Regular | 9 | 14,007 | 60 |
| Sep 16, 2019 | LALA Galaxy7–2Sporting KCSKC | Regular | 9 | 22,465 | 60 |
| Oct 8, 2020 | LALA Galaxy3–6PortlandPOR | Regular | 9 | — | 70 |
| Jul 17, 2021 | MTLMontréal5–4CincinnatiCIN | Regular | 9 | — | 70 |
| Oct 27, 2021 | CINCincinnati3–6NashvilleNSH | Regular | 9 | 20,581 | 70 |
| Apr 24, 2022 | NYCNYCFC5–4TorontoTOR | Regular | 9 | 17,626 | 70 |
| May 15, 2022 | PORPortland7–2Sporting KCSKC | Regular | 9 | 23,503 | 60 |
| Aug 2, 2022 | RBNYRed Bulls4–5ColoradoCOL | Regular | 9 | 13,812 | 80 |
| Aug 21, 2023 | STLSt. Louis6–3AustinATX | Regular | 9 | 22,423 | 60 |
| Apr 27, 2025 | NSHNashville7–2ChicagoCHI | Regular | 9 | 24,771 | 60 |
| Sep 13, 2025 | ATLAtlanta4–5ColumbusCLB | Regular | 9 | 41,089 | 90 |
| Sep 6, 2026 | PORPortland5–4MinnesotaMIN | Regular | 9 | 20,632 | 70 |
| Apr 25, 1998 | COLColorado4–4ChicagoCHI | Regular | 8 | 10,736 | 70 |
| Jun 7, 1998 | DCD.C.4–4DallasDAL | Regular | 8 | 13,454 | 70 |
| Jun 24, 1998 | METMetroStars5–3New EnglandNE | Regular | 8 | 10,310 | 60 |
| Aug 16, 1998 | CLBColumbus5–3Kansas CityKC | Regular | 8 | 11,922 | 60 |
| Sep 5, 1998 | MIAMiami3–5LA GalaxyLA | Regular | 8 | 14,731 | 70 |
| Sep 30, 1998 | CLBColumbus5–3MetroStarsMET | Playoffs | 8 | 10,996 | 70 |
| Jul 8, 2000 | MIAMiami3–5LA GalaxyLA | Regular | 8 | 8,212 | 70 |
| Aug 20, 2000 | METMetroStars5–3ColoradoCOL | Regular | 8 | 27,897 | 60 |
| Sep 9, 2000 | DCD.C.2–6MiamiMIA | Regular | 8 | 18,893 | 70 |
| May 9, 2001 | TBTampa Bay4–4LA GalaxyLA | Regular | 8 | 6,056 | 70 |
| Jun 2, 2001 | DALDallas2–6MiamiMIA | Regular | 8 | 10,049 | 70 |
| Jul 2, 2003 | METMetroStars4–4San JoseSJ | Regular | 8 | 14,875 | 70 |
| Oct 26, 2003 | CLBColumbus6–2ChicagoCHI | Regular | 8 | 19,404 | 60 |